April 23rd, 2009 | Published in Google Android
Hi, developers! I hope you've heard about the early-look version of the Android 1.5 SDK that we recently released. There are some great new features in there, but don't get too excited yet -- some of you will need to fix some problems in your apps before you can start taking advantage of Android 1.5.
We've done some fairly extensive testing of the popular apps on the Android Market, and it turns out that a few of those apps use some bad techniques that cause them to crash or behave strangely on Android 1.5. The list below is based on our observations of five ways that we've seen bad apps fail on 1.5. You can think of these as "anti-patterns" (that is, techniques to avoid) for Android development. If you've written an app with the Android 1.0 or 1.1 SDKs, you'll need to pay close attention.
Technique to Avoid, #1: Using Internal APIs
Even though we've always strongly advised against doing so, some developers have chosen to use unsupported or internal APIs. For instance, many developers are using the internal brightness control and bluetooth toggle APIs that were present in 1.0 and 1.1. A bug -- which is now fixed in Android 1.5 -- allowed apps to use those APIs without requesting permission. As a result, apps that use those APIs will break on 1.5. There are other changes to unsupported APIs in 1.5 besides these, so if you've used internal APIs in your apps, you need to update your apps to stop doing so. Even if they don't break on Android 1.5, there's a good chance they will on some later version. (There's some good news, though: because "flashlight" apps are so popular, we've added the "screenBrightness" field on the WindowManager.LayoutParams class just for that use case.)
Technique to Avoid, #2: Directly Manipulating Settings
Okay, strictly speaking this one isn't evil, since this is a change in behavior that we made to Android itself. But we made it because some developers were doing naughty things: a number of apps were changing system settings silently without even notifying the user. For instance, some apps turn on GPS without asking the user, and others might turn on data roaming.
As a result, applications can no longer directly manipulate the values of certain system Settings, even if they previously had permission to do so. For instance, apps can no longer directly turn on or off GPS. These apps won't crash, but the APIs in question now have no effect, and do nothing. Instead, apps will need to issue an Intent to launch the appropriate Settings configuration screen, so that the user can change these settings manually. For details, see the android.provider.Settings.Secure class, which you can find in the 1.5_pre SDK documentation (and later). Note that only Settings that were moved to the Settings.Secure class are affected. Other, less sensitive, settings will continue to have the same behavior as in Android 1.1.
Technique to Avoid, #3: Going Overboard with Layouts
Due to changes in the View rendering infrastructure, unreasonably deep (more than 10 or so) or broad (more than 30 total) View hierarchies in layouts are now likely to cause crashes. This was always a risk for excessively complex layouts, but you can think of Android 1.5 as being better than 1.1 at exposing this problem. Most developers won't need to worry about this, but if your app has very complicated layouts, you'll need to put it on a diet. You can simplify your layouts using the more advanced layout classes like FrameLayout and TableLayout.
Technique to Avoid, #4: Bad Hardware Assumptions
Android 1.5 includes support for soft keyboards, and there will soon be many devices that run Android but do not have physical keyboards. If your application assumes the presence of a physical keyboard (such as if you have created a custom View that sinks keypress events) you should make sure it degrades gracefully on devices that only have soft keyboards. For more information on this, keep on eye on this blog as we'll be posting more detailed information about handling the new soft keyboards.
Technique to Avoid, #5: Incautious Rotations
Devices running Android 1.5 and later can automatically rotate the screen, depending on how the user orients the device. Some 1.5 devices will do this by default, and on all others it can be turned on by the user. This can sometimes result in unpredictable behavior from applications that do their own reorientations (whether using the accelerometer, or something else.) This often happens when applications assume that the screen can only rotate if the physical keyboard is exposed; if the device lacks a physical keyboard, these apps do not expect to be reoriented, which is a coding error. Developers should be sure that their applications can gracefully handle being reoriented at any time.
Also, apps that use the accelerometer directly to reorient themselves sometimes compete with the system doing the same thing, with odd results. And finally, some apps that use the accelerometer to detect things like shaking motions and that don't lock their orientation to portrait or landscape, often end up flipping back and forth between orientations. This can be irritating to the user. (You can lock your app's orientation to portrait or landscape using the 'android:screenOrientation' attribute in your AndroidManifest.xml.)
Have any of your apps used one of these dubious techniques? If so, break out your IDE, duct tape, and spackle, and patch 'em up. I'm pretty excited by the new features in the Android 1.5 SDK, and I look forward to seeing your apps on my own 1.5-equipped phone -- but I can't, if they won't run! Fortunately, the fixes for these are pretty simple, and you can start fixing all of the above even with the 1.1_r1 SDK release.
By the way, if you'd like to fully immerse yourself in Android 1.5, join us at Google I/O! It's my pleasure to shamelessly plug an event that's shaping up to be the Android developer event of the year. We've added two more sessions—one on multimedia jujitsu, and a particularly interesting session on the Eyes-Free Android project—with even more yet to come. I thought Google I/O was a pretty killer event last year, and this year's looking even better, especially in terms of Android content.
I hope to meet many of you there, but either way, Happy Coding!